Spanish Italian
19540 Users    

Transistor Techniques - Transistor Measurements

  Download PDF version of the Article
Transistors are current amplifiers. Their greatest limitation is that they are temperature-sensitive. That is, their characteristics vary with temperature. Important transistor characteristics are de­scribed by the symbols: Ico, Icbo,  and Rout. Ico, Icbo are leakage currents; $ is current gain. Rout is the output impedance of a common (grounded) emitter transistor.

Test methods

Test methods for these parameters are important because these measurements are the most economical way to identify satisfactory transistors. Usually there is no need to measure other parameters. For instance, base resistance rb and emitter resistance re are rela­tively unimportant in general service work (unless either is open- or short-circuited, in which case replacement is obviously required) and need no further discussion. The general specifications for good transistors are that rb shall be less than 1,000 ohms and re less than 50 ohms, at room temperature, when emitter current is 1 ma and collector voltage is 6.

To simplify measurement use the common (grounded) emitter connection and divide transistors into two groups according to the kind of semiconductor used: germanium and silicon junction tran­sistors. Tests for point-contact transistors are omitted because these units have negligible commercial value. Engineers in industry feel that junction transistors eventually will replace point-contact units in most applications.

Measuring lco and lcbo

 
 

 













Fig. 401. Measuring dc leakage current between collector and base. Emitter is open circuited.

Fig. 401 shows Ico, the dc leakage between collector and base when the emitter is open-circuited. lco increases with temperature, and should be smaller than lcbo—the smaller it is, the "cleaner" the transistor. Clean transistors have longer life because they are relatively free of contaminating materials.

Fig. 402 shows Icb„, the dc leakage between collector and emitter when the base is open-circuited. Icb„ increases with temperature. It is a measure of collector efficiency—the smaller it is, the higher the efficiency.

Both Ico and Icbo increase with age. The tests in Figs. 401 and 402 are the first step in determining whether a transistor can still be used or if replacement is necessary. If Ico and Icbo are erratic, or larger than specified, the transistor should not be used.

Current gain in common-emitter transistors is described in three ways. By current gain (dc),   = Ic/Ib; by incremental current gain (dc), b = lc/lb; and small signal current gain, beta or   — dic/ dib. The ratio Ic/Ib is often used to describe current gain (dc) in power transistors. It is substituted for ac measurements when the huge current passed through some high-power units exceeds the rating of available radio components. Incremental current gain b is the ratio of incremental changes in collector and base dc (for con­stant collector voltage Vc). Small-signal (ac) current gain p is the gain from collector to base with the output short-circuited (for con­stant Et) . The latter two items describe gain for medium- and low-powered transistors.

 
Rout is the output impedance of a common-emitter transistor. It should be large because it decreases with increasing temperature.

Germanium Junction Transistors

Early plastic-encapsuled transistors were unreliable. Moisture and impurities, trapped during the encapsulation process, "poisoned" the germanium heart of the transistor. This slow killing process caused unstable operation and failure. Several im­portant facts were learned during the evaluation of plastic-coated transistors. First, transistors must be assembled under surgically clean conditions. Second, rigorous factory tests were necessary if quality and performance were to be maintained. Third, the units had to be enclosed in hermetically sealed containers. For example, transistors encapsuled in plastic had relatively large Ico and Icbo readings. When the same units were assembled under surgical conditions and mounted in hermetically sealed cases, these current readings dropped appreciably.



Fig. 402. Measuring dc leakage current between collector and emitter. Base is open circuited.

The Ico reading (Fig. 401) for most hermetically sealed, small-signal transistors should be less than 18amp at room temperature, with —22.5 volts between collector and base. The manufacturer of 2N43 and 2N43A p-n-p transistors specifies that Ico shall be less than 10 amp at room temperature, with —45 volts between collector and base. This should become an industry-wide standard.
 
The Icbo reading (Fig. 402) for most hermetically sealed, small-signal transistors should be less than 125 amp at room temperature, with —6 volts between collector and emitter.Both Icbo and Ico increase when a warm soldering iron is held near a transistor or even if the unit is held in the fingers while making measurements. This is another way of emphasizing that current increases with temperature. It is illustrated in graphs of Ico versus temperature on data sheets that accompany most tran­sistors. If current increases slightly with temperature, there is no cause for alarm unless the current is unsteady. This often means defective junctions.

To investigate this further use the circuit in Fig. 403, with an oscilloscope in the dc position and a slow sweep (approximately 200 to 500 sec per centimeter) . Two switches (SI, S2) are used so you can see both the collector-to-base and emitter-to-base patterns on the scope. When either switch is flipped off-on-off, the dc voltage across the resistor deflects the scope beam. Set S3 and the scope gain so the pattern jumps about 1 inch. Good transistors generate patterns that are well-defined step functions (a). If the pattern has poor rise (b) or fall time (c) or is unstable or shows appreciable noise (d), the transistor has a faulty junction.

 

Fig. 403. Circuit tests p-n-p junctions. Scope is in dc position with slow sweep.

Transistor noise.

Let's clarify the confusion that exists about transistor noise. The confusion began only because the point-contact unit appeared on the market before the junction type. Point-contact transistors have poor noise properties—a great disadvantage. Junction transistors have excellent noise properties. Noise in many junction transistors measures only 3 or 4 db above theoretical (Johnson) noise. Compare this with about 8 db of noise from the 1620 vacuum tube— the best tube as far as noise is concerned. But tube noise increases when the electrodes are subjected to vibration or shock. In junction transistors, noise is related to the ratio of the sizes of collector and emitter junctions. Hence, noise for a given transistor is fixed and does not change appreciably with vibration or shock. Nominally, noise in good junction transistors is from about 10 to 20 db.

Fig. 404. Drawing at the top shows transistor static characteristics. The cir­cuit diagram below it illustrates a method of measuring incremental cur­rent (dc) gain b.

Duality

The duality concept is useful when comparing transistors and vacuum tubes. Base current bias is the dual of grid voltage bias; collector current the dual of plate voltage and collector voltage replaces plate current. In other words, current and voltage func­tions are interchanged when comparing static characteristics of transistors and tubes.

Fig. 404 shows part of a set of transistor static characteristics. The diagram shows how to measure incremental dc current gain. Rl adjusts base bias current from about 1 to 130 amp. With Ec at —6 volts, adjust Rl so that Ic is about 0.3 ma. Note the values of Ic and Ib. Then change Rl slightly and note the new readings in Ic and Ib. Differences in readings are the incremental changes Alc and Ib Values of b vary widely for various transistors of a given type. For this test, practical working limits for b are from about 18 to 140. If b is less than 18, insufficient gain will be obtained. If it is greater than 140, the transistor probably is unstable.

The small-signal current gain beta in low-powered transistors is the dual of  in a triode vacuum tube. A circuit for the measure­ment of  is shown in Fig. 405. The choke should be a UTC HQB-6 or equivalent, and the capacitors pyranol or equivalent non­polarized. The beta factor is defined as collector-to-base current gain with the output short-circuited. Adjust Rl so that Ic is 1 ma. Set El to 1 volt at 1 kc. Resistor R2 essentially shorts out the output.

Fig. 405.  Circuit for measuring beta. Values of beta vary widely.
 
Values of vary widely for various transistors—from about 15 to more than 200. However, if a designer or experimenter learns to use transistors with an interim spread, say 18 to 36 (some designers like 25 to 50), which is good practice, and designs accordingly, the service technician or experimenter can replace or interchange transistors without much difficulty if he uses units with the same spread. If the original design requires transistors with very low or very high  factors, replacements cannot be made indiscriminately. Such circuits require especially selected transistors as replacements; otherwise the circuits do not function. The problem of having to select transistors with special characteristics has been a headache in servicing many preamplifier circuits.
 
The alpha factor (collector-to-emitter current gain for the common-base transistor) need not be measured for two reasons. First, alpha can be calculated if beta is known; that is,
Secondly, beta magnifies or amplifies transistor properties more accurately.  For example, reconsider the problem of having to select transistors to make an amplifier work. Specifying a beta spread from about 25 to 50 to obtain reliable amplification describes the situation more adequately than an alpha spread of from about 0.961 to about 0.980.
 
Output Impedance
 
The output impedance Rout of a common-emitter transistor (the dual of a grounded-cathode triode tube) is the other parameter about which information is needed to determine transistor reliability. The value of Rout should be large because it decreases with increasing temperature, high collector currents and voltage and with age.
 

Fig. 406.   Measuring output impedance. Impedance values for transistors cover a wide  range  with  an  average  of about 40,000 ohms.

There are several circuits for measuring impedance, but most of them are lacking in one or more respects. Probably the most economical way to establish the magnitude of Rout is to take data for a given transistor and plot the Ic — Ec common-emitter characteristic and then determine Rout when Ic is 1 ma and Ec is 10 volts. Fig. 406 shows the process for an n-p-n transistor.Rout is the cotangent of the angle © or the ratio of E0/l0,and varies widely from transistor to transistor. Practical working limits are from about 25,000 to 65,000 ohms, with an average value of about 40,000.

Power Transistors

Germanium power transistors have a different design than the small-signal units just described. Essentially, power units have a larger collector junction area. And since large amounts of heat are liberated in this area (about 1 /50 square inch in the Minneapolis-Honeywell type 2N57 p-n-p power transistor), adequate cooling must be provided. Otherwise, the junction would overheat and be destroyed. The 2N57 is cooled by mounting the collector junction on a copper stud. Then the stud (Fig. 407) is attached to a metal chassis (heat sink) to permit rapid dissipation of heat. The photograph, Fig. 408 shows a 2N57 attached to a chassis. Because of this design, the 2N57 is rated at a dc collector dissipation of 20 watts, of which 6 watts theoretically, can be converted to useful ac output power.

Fig. 407. Diagram shows how to attach 2N57 power transistor to the chassis. This mounting method permits rapid dissipa­tion of heat.

Measurements of Ico and I,.b„ for power transistors are made with the circuits of Figs. 401 and 402. But a milliammeter is substituted for the microammeter and a larger battery is used. The manufacturer specifies that Ic„ for the 2N57 shall be less than 5 ma with —70 volts between collector and base at room temperature, and Icb0 shall be less than 27 ma with —70 volts on the collector.

Since available radio components will not handle the large currents passed by some high-power transistors, probably the best gain parameter to measure is current gain (dc). For example, attach a 2N57 to a chassis in the common-emitter circuit (Fig. 409) . With Ec at 2.5 volts, adjust Rl until Ic. is 100 ma. The current gain, check the data sheets for the upper limit of Ic and Ib to avoid damaging the transistors or test equipment by excessively large currents (up to 5 amperes in some high-power transistors) should fall between the limits of 10 and 20 for good transistors. For the dc current gain measurement of other power transistors.
 
The collector load resistance for most germanium power transistors is determined by the upper design limits of collector voltage and current. For the 2N57 these limits are 60 volts peak, and 0.8 ampere. Thus, collector load resistance for maximum power is 60/0.8 = 75 ohms. High-powered units rated at 50 to 60 watts dc collector dissipation (Ic = 5 amperes) will require load resistances of about 10 ohms 

Fig. 408. A 2N57 attached to a chassis. The paper clip furnishes an indication of comparative sizes. The useful ac output power of this transistor is approximately six watts.   The mounting technique is an important factor in heat dissipation.

Silicon Junction Transistors

Available silicon junction transistors are of the n-p-n grown junction type. Their principal value is that they can be used at higher temperatures—around 150° C for example. This is because silicon has a higher energy gap (1.1 electron volts) than germanium (0.72 electron volt) . So since the energy gap between filled and conduction bands is large, the intrinsic contribution to conductivity is reduced greatly.

As far as test methods are concerned, we are interested in the same parameters mentioned earlier. The same test circuits can be used (except that battery and meter connections must be reversed for n-p-n transistors).

At room temperatures, Ico and Icbo for low- and medium-powered units should be less than 2 amp with 22.5 volts on the collector.

When a silicon unit is operated at 100° C, Ic„ should be less than 12 Liamp. Noise in silicon units is slightly higher than in germanium units, but is objectionable only in units with high beta factors. Since p adequately describes the performance of available silicon units, and since leakage currents are so small, the dc and incremental dc current gain tests can be postponed until high-power (10 watts or greater) units are available.



Fig. 409. Measuring current gain (dc). The  current  gain  (beta) should   be between 10 and 20.

The spread in  for both low- and medium-powered silicon units is from about 4 to more than 75. There is no official recommendation regarding practical working limits. Some designers and service technicians use an unofficial rule of thumb from about 18 to 36 (as measured with 6 volts on the collector).

 

Fig. 410. Silicon junction power transistor attached directly to metal chassis.

Output impedances (Fig. 406) of between 15,000 and 80,000 ohms (common-emitter circuit) give satisfactory results. Rout varies widely from unit to unit.

The Ico and Icbo readings of silicon medium-power units are small. One experimental unit has readings of less than 10 amp at room temperature with 45 volts on the collector. These Ico and ICbo readings for the Texas Instrument type X-15 power unit (rated at 1 watt) should be less than 5 amp at room temperature with 45 volts on the collector. A silicon junction transistor attached to a chassis (heat sink) appears in Fig. 410.

Heat Sink

A practical consideration worth noting is the requirement for heat removal from the power transistor. Transistor manufacturers' specifications differ widely with respect to the maximum power which can be dissipated safely in free air. At higher levels, the transistor must be mounted in close contact with a metallic mass (heat sink or dissipator) which will remove heat generated by normal operation. In some instances, a satisfactory heat sink is obtained when the the transistor is bolted to the chassis, provided the chassis has sufficient area and thickness. However, the cooling structure of most power transistors is connected internally to one of the electrodes, usually the collector, and push-pull transistors accordingly cannot be mounted without at least a thin mica insulator between their shells and chassis, otherwise their collectors would be short-circuited by the chassis.
 
Fig. 411. A power-transistor output amplifier

Dc voltage requirements

An attractive feature of the power transistor is its low dc voltage requirement. However, it is as true of power transistors as of other matters that one does not receive something for nothing. High current is the price paid for this low voltage. The high direct currents of the power transistor impose rather severe requirements on the design of the coupling transformers and on that of the power supply. While on this subject, it should be mentioned that standard, catalogued transformers are unsatisfactory at the low-impedance and high-current levels met in the power transistor. At present, both input and output transformers must either be obtained on special order or built by the user.


The diagram in Fig. 411 shows a typical class-B power-transistor output amplifier stage. Resistor Rl and the battery voltage are selected for a total no-signal collector current of 1 ma. Heavily bypassed emitter stabilization resistors are required if collector current shows a tendency toward "runaway." A typical heat sink would consist of a 25-square-inch chassis, 1/16 inch thick. The maximum-signal current of this stage is 550 ma and maximum power output is 5 watts.

 

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Who's new

  • omiga
  • david-p51
  • anunakin
  • mizort1989
  • drgino
  • ik3nok
  • jjuhlen@gmail.com
  • alimotamed
  • Guge007
  • robertvanreeth@...

Who's online

There are currently 0 users and 40 guests online.